Draft Strategy

Finding 2017's Optimal Draft Approach

By Ben Gretch 8:07am EDT 7/28/17


The key to a successful fantasy football draft seems to rely on nailing a particular position. In 2016, for example, hammering RBs early in the draft was crucial. In 2015, drafting early WRs was the key to victory.

End-of-season point distributions can help show why -- and how we should approach drafts in 2017 (and beyond).

Last year, the advantage of landing a top RB was magnified by the fact that no later-round RBs truly hit. The top 8 finishers in PPR formats were all drafted in the top 21 RBs, and 6 of those 8 were top 12 draft picks at the position.

In 2015, the success of early-WR draft structures was more about end-of-season distributions at the other positions. Top WRs hit, but so did some value guys like Larry Fitzgerald and Doug Baldwin. So you weren’t out in the cold if you waited like you were at RB in 2016.

Where the damage was done to rosters that waited at WR in 2015 was at the other positions. Waiting at WR meant drafting early RBs, and they busted at a high rate. Of the top 7 PPR backs end-of-season, 4 carried preseason ADPs of RB39 or lower.

A similar trend was true at TE, where 4 of the top 6 finishers were drafted outside the top 100 overall picks. And at QB, where Cam Newton, Tom Brady, Blake Bortles, and Carson Palmer were all top 6 QBs. Brady was QB8 in preseason ADP and the others were all QB13 or lower.

Naturally, fantasy owners that target a specific position in the early part of drafts are more likely to be bargain shopping in the other areas. So in 2015, drafting WR early meant spending picks at QB, RB, and TE in the areas of the draft where values proved to be. In 2016, drafting RBs early meant focusing on other positions in the middle and later rounds, and not wasting picks on RBs that ultimately didn’t pan out.

We often discuss fantasy draft structures, searching for the optimal areas of the draft to target the various positions. Because that has proven to vary wildly in recent seasons, there’s been a tendency to overcorrect to the most recent results. But at the same time, the value of employing something like the Zero RB strategy in 2015 -- and the resulting spike in WR ADP in 2016 drafts -- isn’t what caused no late-round RBs to crack the top 8 at the position in 2016.

While identifying draft value and going RB-heavy early paid off in 2016, we must still recognize the separation of the contrarian 2016 strategy and the sequencing of results that emphasized its success. In that way, seeking out the next contrarian strategy in 2017 is, ironically, overcorrecting to the most recent results.

If we only looked at 2014 results, we’d see Odell Beckham’s monster second half run as a reason to target young WRs late in drafts. 2015 would tell us later-round RBs and TEs like Devonta Freeman and Jordan Reed grow on trees. In 2013, early-round RB Jamaal Charles posted a 5-TD fantasy semifinal performance so epic that you’d really have no choice but to go RB in the 1st. The biggest thing to recognize is each distribution is a sample of 1. We can’t draw meaningful conclusions from that.

So, we must take a longer view. But how long? The league has changed significantly over time, so going back to the early ‘90s wouldn’t be particularly applicable to the modern NFL.

There are also other factors in play here, including how fantasy drafters have valued various positions over time. To account for this, I analyzed within positions. I aggregated positional ADP vs. end-of-season finishes over the 7 seasons since 2010. That’s still not a huge sample, but it should give us some broader trends to analyze. I pulled 12-team PPR redraft ADP data from My Fantasy League’s awesome database using only drafts after August 25th, excluding mocks.

Sorry, the rest of this content is reserved for DS Insiders.

Get instant access to read it all.

Get the insider information

Already a DS Insider? Login now

Share This!

Agree? Disagree? Tell us what you think in the comments:

comments powered by Disqus

Related Fantasy Football

Takeaways from Early FFPC Drafts

Let's run through a couple of February FFPC drafts and pick out some lessons learned at every position.

2:02pm EST 2/25/19 Read More
Premium Content Early 2019 Best-Ball Draft Tiers

Fantasy football drafts have officially started for 2019 already. If you plan to get in on the action, we've got some player tiers to help you crush it.

11:01pm EST 1/10/19 Read More
Premium Content FFPC Playoff Challenge Strategy

Players to target and avoid at every position for the FFPC Playoff Challenge

4:01pm EST 1/2/19 Read More
Premium Content Playoff IDP Rankings

If you're serious enough about your fantasy football to be in a playoffs league with IDPs, then we've got you covered for draft day ...

3:01pm EST 1/1/19 Read More
Premium Content Playoff Rankings

Overall and positional rankings for your playoff-long fantasy football leagues.

2:12pm EST 12/31/18 Read More
2018 Team Defense Draft Strategy

Picking a D/ST (or 2?) is a lot different than drafting the other positions. Here's our guide for what you should do on draft day ... and well into the regular season.

8:08am EDT 8/31/18 Read More
Fantasy Football Podcast: The Perfect Draft 8-30-18

Is there such a thing as a perfect fantasy football draft? Today we'll try to get close ...

2:08pm EDT 8/30/18 Read More

Read More Articles

Turn your phone into a draft weapon with our FREE APP

Download on the App Store Download on Google Play