Fantasy Draft Recaps

Smola's Pros vs. Joes Draft Recap

By Jared Smola 4:07pm EDT 7/28/16

The fine folks at the FFPC and Fantasy Mojo were kind enough to invite me back for the 2016 Pros vs. Joes Challenge.

As the name suggests, the competition pits industry “Pros” (quotation marks definitely required there) vs. high-stakes veterans (called “Joes” probably for rhyming purposes). There are 6 leagues of 12-teams, each consisting of 6 Pros and 6 Joes.

FFPC rules are in play. That’s 1 PPR for RBs and WRs; 1.5 PPR for TEs. Starting requirements are as follows:

1 QB

2 RBs

2 WRs

1 TE

2 Flex

1 K


Pros vs. Joes is a best-ball league — optimal starting lineups, no waiver wire and no trades. The squad you leave the draft with is your squad for the entire season.

We’ve been digging into MFL10 best-ball strategy for the past year, including a recent podcast. I applied a lot of that knowledge to this draft, while adjusting for the rule differences, of course.

I drew the 5th pick in the November Rain draft. Check out the full draft results here. And give a listen to the High Stakes Fantasy Football Hour’s coverage of the draft.

Here’s a pick-by-pick look at how my squad turned out:

1.05 - David Johnson, RB, Cardinals

Johnson sits #2 overall on an FFPC MVP Board, behind only Antonio Brown. (The ability to start 4 RBs bumps them up the rankings). Easy pick here.

2.08 - Devonta Freeman, RB, Falcons

A much tougher decision here with both Freeman and Jamaal Charles on the board. Charles might be my pick in a month. But for now, I’m going with the healthy guy. Freeman figures to lose some carries to Tevin Coleman this year, but he’ll remain a huge part of the passing game and handle most of the goal-line work.

3.05 - Randall Cobb, WR, Packers

Was hoping to land Doug Martin or Mark Ingram at this spot, but they went with the 2 picks ahead of me. That left me deciding between 2 Packers: Cobb and Eddie Lacy. Cobb was the pick because he’s safer and filled a bigger need after starting with 2 RBs.

4.08 - Matt Forte, RB, Jets

Sniped again with C.J. Anderson going 1 pick ahead of me. Forte is a fine consolation prize. I don’t expect huge rushing numbers, but OC Chan Gailey figures to maximize Forte’s pass-catching ability. He, Freeman and Johnson could give me 3 RBs who catch 50+ passes.

5.05 - Michael Floyd, WR, Cardinals

Pumped to land Floyd here as the 28th WR off the board. He sits considerably higher in our rankings.

6.08 - Julius Thomas, TE, Jaguars

The 1.5 PPR pushes TEs way up the rankings and ADP in FFPC leagues. Eight were already off the board at this point. Thomas got off to a slow start last year, but only 3 TEs scored more points in this format over the final 7 weeks.

7.05 - Frank Gore, RB, Colts

As our data scientist, Jason Phelps, mentioned on the MFL10 strategy podcast, Gore usually marks the end of the RBs we feel comfortable with. Securing 4 lead backs is important in a best-ball league.

8.08 - Michael Crabtree, WR, Raiders

Crabtree isn’t a guy I’ve been drafting much this year. He’s not going to out-target Amari Cooper again. And he probably won’t score another 9 TDs. But I like Crabtree just fine as a WR3. He made sense as the 41st WR drafted here.

9.05 - Willie Snead, WR, Saints

Continuing to add quantity at WR after a RB-heavy start. Snead might lose a few targets to new teammates Coby Fleener and Michael Thomas. But he’s earned Drew Brees’ trust and will remain a key cog in the Saints’ highly productive passing game. Snead turned in 8 top-36 WR weeks last year — tied for 24th most.

10.08 - Austin Seferian-Jenkins, TE, Bucs

My biggest mistake in this draft was waiting too long on a 2nd TE. Sixteen of them flew off the board between the 7th and 10th rounds. Getting ASJ as the 24th TE selected could turn out to be a coup. But I’ll be hurting at the position if he loses the starting job to Cameron Brate.

11.05 - Dorial Green-Beckham, WR, Titans

It wasn’t a good spring for DGB, who was passed on the depth chart by newcomers Rishard Matthews and Tajae Sharpe. But he remains the biggest, most talented WR in Tennessee. And there’s plenty of time for him to win a starting job. Well worth the gamble in the 11th round as my WR5.

12.08 - Marcus Mariota, QB, Titans

13.05 - Ryan Tannehill, QB, Dolphins

QBs plummeted in this draft, as they usually do in leagues with a bunch of sharp owners. I probably would have taken Drew Brees had he not gone 1 pick ahead of me in the 9th. I considered Blake Bortles and Carson Palmer in the 10th. Eli Manning was on my radar in the 11th.

But I was happy to come away with these 2 guys considering the minimal cost. Mariota scored as a top 12 QB in his 11 healthy games as a rookie last year. Tannehill ranked 8th among QBs in 2014 and was a still-decent 15th last season.

14.08 - Terrance Williams, WR, Cowboys

A perfect best-ball WR. With Tony Romo mostly healthy in 2013 and 2014, Williams was held to single-digit PPR points in 18 of 30 games. But he also had 4 outings of 19+ points. I’m expecting at least a couple of big ones in 2016.

15.05 - Kenneth Dixon, RB, Ravens

This rookie has some depth-chart climbing to do but could emerge as Baltimore’s top back. That’d give him big fantasy upside. Justin Forsett was sitting 15th in PPR points among RBs through 10 healthy weeks last year. Buck Allen ranked 3rd from Week 11 on.

16.08 - Pierre Garcon, WR, Redskins

The most boring pick of my draft. But Garcon is still slated to start for an offense that ranked 11th in passing yards and 13th in TDs last year. Garcon provided 7 top-36 WR weeks.

17.05 - Texans DST

18.08 - Josh Lambo, K, Chargers

19.05 - Mike Nugent, K, Bengals

20.08 - Jason Myers, K, Jaguars

21.05 - Buccaneers DST

22.08 - Chargers DST

Our MFL10 research last year found that 3 DSTs was optimal. The volatility of the position makes quantity important. It’s even easier to roster 3 in the FFPC with 28 picks. The same logic applies at K, a similarly volatile position.

All 32 defenses were off the board by Round 23, by the way.

23.05 - Jeff Janis, WR, Packers

24.08 - Maxx Williams, TE, Ravens

25.05 - Colin Kaepernick, QB, 49ers

26.08 - Jaelen Strong, WR, Texans

27.05 - Ty Montgomery, WR, Packers

28.08 - Darren Fells, TE, Cardinals

Rostering both Janis and Montgomery gives me a decent chance of landing Green Bay’s #3 WR.

Strong is coming off a good spring and might be the favorite for the #2 WR spot in Houston.

Blaine Gabbert won’t make it the entire year as the 49ers’ starter, right? I’m expecting Kaepernick to get on the field.

Williams has lots of competition for targets, but Baltimore invested a 2nd-round pick in him just a year ago. Carson Palmer liked what he saw from Fells this spring.

Final Roster:


Marcus Mariota

Ryan Tannehill

Colin Kaepernick


David Johnson

Devonta Freeman

Matt Forte

Frank Gore

Kenneth Dixon


Randall Cobb

Michael Floyd

Michael Crabtree

Willie Snead

Dorial Green-Beckham

Terrance Williams

Pierre Garcon

Jeff Janis

Jaelen Strong

Ty Montgomery


Julius Thomas

Austin Seferian-Jenkins

Maxx Williams

Darren Fells


Josh Lambo

Mike Nugent

Jason Myers





Share This!

Agree? Disagree? Tell us what you think in the comments:

comments powered by Disqus

Related Fantasy Football

Podcast: Perfect Draft and Mailbag 8-15-19

Let's talk about perfect draft strategy, selecting keepers, budgeting for an auction and just generally starting your draft off right.

7:08pm EDT 8/15/19 Read More
Podcast: Preseason Week 1 Reactions

Did David Montgomery play well enough to rocket up the rankings? Is Terry McLaurin set for early stardom in Washington? Should we quit on Dante Pettis? Let's take some time to react -- or overreact -- to the 1st full round of NFL preseason games ...

3:08pm EDT 8/13/19 Read More
Premium Content 11 Fantasy Football Sleepers

Want to find upside in the double-digit rounds of your draft? Of course you do. And here are 11 targets in that range poised to deliver.

9:08pm EDT 8/12/19 Read More
Premium Content Ranking Fantasy's 1st-Rounders by Injury Risk

Which 1st-rounders carry the most and least injury risk this season? Our friends at Sports Injury Predictor have the answers ...

11:08am EDT 8/7/19 Read More
FFPC Best-Ball Live Stream

Even while the DS crew is on the road for the NFL Hall of Fame enshrinement in Canton, we're still drafting. And we can't pass on the upside of Melvin Gordon where he's going ...

8:08am EDT 8/4/19 Read More
Premium Content NFC Backfield Breakdowns

16 backfields. Hundreds of possible outcomes. Let's dig in ...

8:07am EDT 7/26/19 Read More
Podcast: July ADP Check 7-18-19

Panthers receivers are shooting up draft boards. Melvin Gordon Holdout Mania is resetting ADPs in the Chargers' backfield. And QBs are moving all over the place. Let's check in to see how player values have shifted and what that will mean for your fantasy football draft.

11:07pm EDT 7/18/19 Read More

Read More Articles

Turn your phone into a draft weapon with our FREE APP

Download on the App Store Download on Google Play