Show Navigation
Show Menu

Top Plays for Divisional Round Underdog Pick Ems

By Matt Schauf 11:18pm EST 1/19/23

What a way to start the NFL playoffs!

Four straight games delivered 55+ points. Only 1 game didn’t have a team reach 31. Three QBs topped 30 fantasy points. FOUR TEs went over 20 PPR points.

This week has to fall short of that offensive production … right?

The early Underdog Pick Em options, meanwhile, proved a bit more challenging for our numbers.

Justin Jefferson tanked.
Tony Pollard did it on the ground instead of receiving.
Saquon Barkley did it as a receiver, while logging just 9 carries in a win.
Austin Ekeler found the end zone twice but otherwise went quiet on the ground.

Still, we pulled out an 8-9 record on highlighted plays – just the 3rd time all year we've gone 50% or lower in hit rate.

Here’s the season record …

Week 1: 16-8
Week 2: 16-8
Week 3: 11-5
Week 4: 8-9
Week 5: 10-8
Week 6: 13-12
Week 7: 18-6
Week 8: 9-7
Week 9: 13-7
Week 10: 17-14
Week 11: 10-8
Week 12: 18-13
Week 13: 11-6
Week 14: 7-9
Week 15: 22-14
Week 16: 15-11
Week 17: 13-3
Week 18: 8-6
Wild Card: 8-9
Overall: 243-163

Now let’s jump back in for the Divisional Round. Fewer teams, of course, means fewer highlighted plays. And there are interesting options among the 13 below. If you haven’t played before, hit the graphic below to get some free money on Underdog …

Of course, as always, you can compare the Underdog player-prop lines to our fantasy football rankings for the Divisional Round.


Trevor Lawrence, Jaguars
Draft Sharks projection: 269.5 yards
Underdog: 250.5
Difference: 19

Jalen Hurts, Eagles
DS: 234.5
Underdog: 245.5
Difference: -11

QB Total Yards

Trevor Lawrence, Jaguars
Draft Sharks projection: 287.5
Underdog: 267.5
Difference: 20

Daniel Jones, Giants
DS: 260.4
Underdog: 270.5
Difference: -10.1

Josh Allen, Bills
DS: 313.9
Underdog: 324.5
Difference: -10.6

Brock Purdy, 49ers
DS: 236.1
Underdog: 251.5
Difference: -15.4

Jalen Hurts, Eagles
DS: 286.4
Underdog: 304.5
Difference: -18.1

This seems like a good time to point out – in case you didn’t already realize it – that the total-yards props for QBs always sit higher than the sum of their passing and rushing lines. That’s particularly reflected here. None of the QB lines for passing yards or rushing yards sits far enough apart from our projections as of this writing to highlight them here. Yet half the QBs pop as potential “under” bets on total yards.

I can’t say I could comfortably bet the under on either Allen or Hurts. But Allen has reached this week’s total-yards line just 4 times over his past 11 games. Hurts has reached this week’s line just 5 times all season.


Dallas Goedert, TE, Eagles
Draft Sharks projection: 57.1 yards
Underdog: 48.5
Difference: 8.6

Dalton Schultz, TE, Cowboys
DS: 38.2
Underdog: 46.5
Difference: -8.3

Schultz went nuts last week vs. a Bucs D that added 4% to opponent TE scoring all year. This week finds the 49ers, who have sapped 19.5% of TE production – 7th toughest by our adjusted fantasy points allowed.

Goedert, meanwhile, gets a Giants D that just finished playing conveyor belt to T.J. Hockenson for the 2nd time this year.


Elijah Mitchell, 49ers
Draft Sharks projection: 38.5 yards
Underdog: 30.5
Difference: 8

Tony Pollard, Cowboys
DS: 40.1
Underdog: 48.5
Difference: -8.4

RB Total Yards

Elijah Mitchell, 49ers
Draft Sharks projection: 44.9 yards
Underdog: 36.5
Difference: 8.4

Joe Mixon, Bengals
DS: 83.2
Underdog: 75.5
Difference: 7.7

Mitchell ran for just 2 yards last week but carried 9 times and drew 3 targets, 12 opportunities vs. Christian McCaffrey’s 17.

Related Fantasy Football

Top Quarterbacks (QB) For Fantasy Football 2023

Top Quarterbacks (QB) For Fantasy Football 2023

11:15am EDT 5/30/23

If you want one of the top fantasy quarterbacks on draft day, you'll need to pay more than last year. Matt says you can find value beyond the top shelf, though.

Read More »
Top Tight Ends (TE) For Fantasy Football in 2023

Top Tight Ends (TE) For Fantasy Football in 2023

11:48am EDT 5/25/23

This year's top fantasy tight ends include some guys who stepped up in 2022, some guys who let you down ... and maybe a surprise or two.

Read More »
Best Ball Mania IV Top Values

Best Ball Mania IV Top Values

4:25pm EDT 5/1/23

If you're drafting Underdog fantasy football teams right now, then you'll want to know about these value picks. Matt Schauf brings you seven players ready to smash their low ADPs.

Read More »
Way Too Early Fantasy Football Rankings 2023

Way Too Early Fantasy Football Rankings 2023

12:10pm EDT 4/20/23

Josh Allen or Patrick Mahomes? Justin Jefferson or Ja'Marr Chase? Let's answer those questions (and more) with a look at way too early 2023 fantasy football rankings.

Read More »
NFL Cap Space 2023 | Getting a Fantasy Read

NFL Cap Space 2023 | Getting a Fantasy Read

4:35pm EST 3/6/23

The Chicago Bears can afford whomever they want. The Tampa Bay Buccaneers have no room under the salary cap. Find out which teams will be most affected by NFL cap space for 2023 and what that means for your best ball drafting right now.

Read More »
2023 NFL Free Agency Predictions

2023 NFL Free Agency Predictions

2:45pm EST 2/27/23

Lamar Jackson, Saquon Barkley, and Jakobi Meyers rank among the biggest names of 2023 NFL free agency. Where might they and 7 other key players land? And how will that impact your fantasy football team?

Read More »
Premium Content Premium ContentDynasty Buy-Sell-Hold Report #1

Dynasty Buy-Sell-Hold Report #1

10:57am EST 2/1/23

Deshaun Watson dominated NFL news for a while. Is he ready now to impact your dynasty fantasy football league? He leads this list of 11 players to look at for offseason dynasty trades ...

Read More »
Dominate your Fantasy League with
the Ultimate Tool Stack
In the heat of a draft, you want as much intel as possible. The key is integrating that into one simple, powerful tool.
Dominate your Fantasy League with
the Ultimate Tool Stack
In the heat of a draft, you want as much intel as possible. The key is integrating that into one simple, powerful tool.
3D Projections

3D Projections

3D Projections: True Dimension of Every Player’s Potential

Based on our award-winning projections, an axis of data points give insights far deeper than a ranking

View Our Accuracy Awards View Our Accuracy Awards »

Advice Draft Strategy

Advice That’s Actionable on Draft Day

Round-by-Round Draft Strategy Guides, Sleepers, Undervalued Players, Busts and Handcuffs

3D Projections

Draft War Room

Draft War Room: Intel Turned Into Killer Picks

Command your entire draft with a dynamic tool synced to your league. Updating and adapting in real time.

3D Projections

Keep Dominating Throughout The Season

Quickly find the free-agent gems, pull the trigger on the perfect trade & make the right start/sit decisions.

Keep Dominating
Draft Sharks

$6/month thereafter, billed semi-annually, one-click cancel anytime.

Turn your phone into a draft weapon with our FREE APP

Download on the App Store Get It on Google Play