Most Accurate Fantasy Football Experts 2026: Jody Smith of Draft Sharks
Who is the Most Accurate Fantasy Football Expert?
It’s our own Jody Smith, who finished first among 157 fantasy analysts in the FantasyPros Multi-Year Draft Rankings Accuracy contest.
When you combine the accuracy results across QB, RB, WR, and TE over the past three seasons, nobody proved more accurate in projecting how things would finish.
That's a long track record of deadly accurate rankings!
Some highlights that vaulted Jody to the top:
- Ranking 1st at RB
- Finishing 9th at TE
- Checking in 13th at WR
He even finished eighth in DST rankings and seventh in IDPs. Those positions don't factor into the overall rankings, but Jody's result fell right in line with the other spots.
How does the FantasyPros competition work?
They compare end-of-season rankings by total fantasy points scored to preseason rankings, measuring which experts came closest to matching their rankings to the actual results.
Which Fantasy Football Site Has the Best Draft Rankings?
Jody's 2025 title continues a strong tradition of rankings accuracy at Draft Sharks.
- Kevin English had the most accurate draft rankings for the 2024 season.
- Jared Smola won FantasyPros’ Multi-Year Draft Accuracy award in 2023.
- Jody, Jared, and Kevin all rank inside the top 13 for Multi-Year Draft Accuracy.
- Matt Schauf has won the FantasyPros IDP Accuracy title twice.
- We’ve also taken home three other draft accuracy awards since 2012.
These aren’t self-proclaimed titles. They’re third-party, data-driven results from one of the most respected accuracy trackers in fantasy football.
So if you're asking:
- Who are the most accurate fantasy football experts?
- Which site consistently nails their draft rankings?
- What source delivers across redraft, dynasty, and IDP?
You're in the right place. And we’ve got the receipts.
Wanna Know How We Build Those Rankings?
Why Do the Most Accurate Fantasy Football Rankings Matter?
Winning contests is great, but that’s not our goal.
Our guys work diligently on generating those accurate fantasy football rankings because that’s how you win fantasy football leagues. And here’s how you can ramp up the accuracy even further for your fantasy football draft:
- Sync your team at Draft Sharks to automatically import your league settings and rules.
- Use the Draft War Room to get real-time pick suggestions based on our projections applied to your league rules.
The Draft War Room will follow along as you draft and keep track of all the action to make sure you’re ready at every turn.
Try the Sync and Draft War Room Today!
TIP
Looking to learn more about how the Draft War Room works? This article lays out the details of the only fantasy football cheat sheet you'll need.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the most accurate fantasy football expert?
According to Fantasy Pros, Jody Smith of Draft Sharks was rated the most accurate fantasy football expert across the last three seasons.
Who gives the best fantasy football advice?
Draft Sharks gives the best fantasy football advice based on their accuracy awards. Jody Smith won the FantasyPros Multi-Year Draft Accuracy award. He, Jared Smola, and Kevin English all rank among the top 13 in Multi-Year Draft Accuracy.
Who are the best fantasy football predictors?
The best fantasy football predictors are Draft Sharks. They’ve won multiple accuracy awards since 1999, including the latest FantasyPros Multi-Year Draft Accuracy award. Past awards have also included IDP rankings accuracy and even DFS accuracy.
What is the most accurate fantasy football app?
The most accurate fantasy football app is Draft Sharks. They won the latest FantasyPros Multi-Year Draft Accuracy award, as well as seven other previous awards for draft rankings accuracy.
