Fantasy Draft Recaps

Smola's Pros vs. Joes Draft Recap

By Jared Smola 8:08am EDT 8/4/17

We often write about being flexible in drafts. Adjusting strategy on the fly. Jumping on value wherever it presents itself.

My 2017 Pros vs. Joes Draft was a test of whether I’d practice what I preach.

I’ve been a big believer in loading up on RBs early in best-ball drafts since we published our MFL10 Strategy Guide a couple of years ago. The thinking: It’s easier to find “start-worthy” weeks at WR later in drafts than it is at RB.

But that same study concluded that value is king. Drafting guys later than ADP — regardless of position — trumps any set positional strategy.

I rolled with value early on in this FFPC-style best-ball draft. With the “Big 3” RBs coming off the board with the first 3 picks, Antonio Brown was clearly the selection at 1.04. And with 7 more RBs going in the next 16 picks, Dez Bryant represented the top value at 2.09.

How’d the rest of the draft play out? I’ll run through it below.

But first, for those unfamiliar with this format, here’s the skinny:

  • Start 1 QB, 2 RBs, 2 WRs, 1 TE, 1 Flex, 1 K, 1 DEF
  • Standard scoring with 1 PPR for RBs and WRs
  • 1.5 PPR for TEs
  • Best-ball format (no waivers, no trades, optimal lineup set at the conclusion of each week)

Here’s how I drafted from the 4 spot in this winner-take-all league. You can check out the full draft board here.


1.04 - Antonio Brown, WR, Steelers

David Johnson and Le’Veon Bell went 1-2, as expected. Ezekiel Elliott remains my #3 overall player in this format — even with his looming suspension. But he came off the board at 1.03.

That left Brown as a fairly easy pick, despite my preference to go RB-heavy early. Brown has finished 1st at his position in PPR points in 3 straight seasons and brings an incredible combination of weekly upside and safety. He led all WRs with 5 top-5 weeks last year and dropped outside the top-36 in just 3 of his 15 games.


2.09 - Dez Bryant, WR, Cowboys

I would have taken any of our top 10 PPR RBs had they made it here. But the last one (Jay Ajayi) came off the board 1 pick in front of me.

So I again abandoned the early-RB strategy for value. After returning from an early-season knee injury, Bryant ranked 10th among WRs in PPR points from Week 10 on.


Sorry, the rest of this content is reserved for DS Insiders.

Get instant access to read it all.

Get the insider information

Already a DS Insider? Login now

Share This!

Agree? Disagree? Tell us what you think in the comments:

comments powered by Disqus

Related Fantasy Football

Premium Content 6 Offensive Lines Poised to Help or Harm Your Fantasy Team

Offensive line quality is baked into our rankings and projections. But let's examine a handful of units that warrant extra attention.

9:07am EDT 7/15/19 Read More
Podcast: AFC North Projections 7-11-19

Let's wrap up the series by pointing out some underrated Bengals, some overrated QBs and the big changes that will shape fantasy football in the AFC North in 2019.

11:07am EDT 7/12/19 Read More
Premium Content Who's Due for More or Fewer TD Passes in 2019?

3 big-name QBs likely to see a dip in TD production this season -- plus 2 good bets for more scores.

7:07am EDT 7/9/19 Read More
Draft Sharks Fantasy Football Podcast: AFC South Projections 6-26-19

Andrew Luck, Deshaun Watson, DeAndre Hopkins, T.Y. Hilton ... Oh yeah, and the Jaguars and Titans also play in this division. Who will be the top values when you draft, and which big names should you avoid?

11:06pm EDT 6/26/19 Read More
Draft Sharks Fantasy Football Podcast: NFC South Projections 6-19-19

The Buccaneers have a new coach. The Falcons have a new OC -- who's been there before. Panthers QB Cam Newton has a newly repaired shoulder. And we have a clear new version of the Saints. What's it all mean for your fantasy football drafts?

7:06pm EDT 6/19/19 Read More
Fantasy Football Podcast: AFC West Projections 6-13-19

What will Antonio Brown mean for the Raiders? What do a new QB and new coaching staff mean for the Broncos? Which Charger is getting drafted way too early? And how much will Tyreek Hill even play in 2019? The answers could shape how you draft ...

1:06pm EDT 6/12/19 Read More
Is Carson Wentz Ready to Win You a Championship?

Carson Wentz just got his money from the Eagles. Now he looks poised to deliver you big value in fantasy football drafts.

10:06am EDT 6/11/19 Read More

Read More Articles

Turn your phone into a draft weapon with our FREE APP

Download on the App Store Download on Google Play