
Colts RB Jonathan Taylor carried 16 times for 83 yards in Sunday’s win over Miami. He added 2 catches for 20 yards on an 18% target share, but the story of his Week 10 goes beyond the counting stats.
2026 Fantasy Football Impact: Seth McGowan Is Still a Threat
Taylor predictably took advantage of a Miami run defense missing DL Zach Sieler. His 5.2 yards per carry marked his second-best average of the season.
But the backfield split grabbed our attention. Taylor handled 53% of the carries, only slightly ahead of Seth McGowan's 40%. That gap narrowed considerably from Week 9, when Taylor led 62% to 29%.
McGowan also scored the backfield's only TD, powering through the middle from four yards out. He nearly added another but went down inside the one. Taylor got the next carry following the two-minute warning but failed to punch it in.
The Colts opted to keep Taylor through the trade deadline, but they're not contenders and appear set to continue using a two-man backfield. The rookie has proven worthy of the work, tallying 5.8, 7.5, and 6.4 yards per carry over his past three. None of his runs went for negative yardage against Miami.
Still, McGowan remains a thin flex option. He's caught only 5 passes for 9 yards all season, and scoring opportunities figure to be limited most weeks in a shaky Colts offense.
But his growing role threatens Taylor's fantasy ceiling. JT has finished RB13, RB27, RB18, and RB20 over the past four weeks, disappointing relative to his Round 1 ADP. A neutral matchup with Houston and a negative draw against the Giants await before a Week 13 bye.