Show Navigation
Show Menu

Draft Strategy

Where was the Value in 2018 Fantasy Drafts? (Part 1)

By Jared Smola 8:07am EDT 7/22/19

I went through this exercise 4 years ago, looking back at 2014 fantasy drafts to formulate a strategy for 2015. The biggest takeaway: spend early-round picks on RBs.

That was particularly noteworthy because it was during the middle of the Zero RB craze. The recommendation had mixed results in 2015, with early-rounders like Adrian Peterson, Matt Forte and Lamar Miller cashing in — but others like Marshawn Lynch, Eddie Lacy and C.J. Anderson busting hard.

With the fantasy landscape much different now than it was then, I thought it’d be interesting to run through the same exercise, looking back at 2018’s optimal strategy as we approach our 2019 fantasy drafts.

I’ll steal from 2015 Jared to explain why this is important …

Player evaluation is the most important part of fantasy football. That’s why we spend the majority of every offseason analyzing talent and situation to create our projections and rankings.

But player evaluation is also the hardest part of fantasy football. The end-of-season fantasy rankings never look like the rankings you draft from in August.

While we’re always looking for ways to improve our projections and rankings, we can also become better fantasy footballers by deploying a better draft strategy.

When I say draft strategy, I’m talking about when and how often we target each position. Fantasy success ultimately boils down to picking the right players. But we can improve our odds of picking the right players by understanding the positions that present the most value at different points of drafts.

Makes sense, right?

So how do we figure out when and how often we should be targeting each position? There are surely other methods, but how I’m doing it is by looking at the average “starter weeks” per player found at each position in each round of 2018 fantasy drafts.

Stick with me.

We define a “starter week” as a top 12 QB finish, a top 24 RB finish, a top 36 WR finish, a top 12 TE finish and a top 12 DEF finish. We can determine where the value was in 2018 fantasy drafts by calculating how many starter weeks an average player produced at each round and at each position.

Let’s look at a quick example. Last year, WRs Antonio Brown, DeAndre Hopkins and Odell Beckham were picked in the 1st round of average fantasy drafts. Those 3 guys combined for 40 WR starter weeks. Divide that by 3 and we get an average of 13.3 starter weeks from a 1st-round WR last year.

Let’s look at that data for each position for the first 16 rounds of average 2018 drafts. For the purposes of this project, we’ll consider any player drafted outside the first 16 rounds a free agent.


Score another one for the “wait-on-a-QB” crowd. Rounds 9 and 10 presented more QB value than any other round last year. Patrick Mahomes (14 starter weeks) and Matt Ryan (12) were the gems in that range. Jared Goff (7) was just fine, too.

Goff actually provided more starter weeks than 2 of the 4 QBs who went in the first 4 rounds of drafts last year, Aaron Rodgers and Tom Brady. The other 2 — Russell Wilson and Deshaun Watson -- both recorded 10 starter weeks.

Four QBs picked in the 11th round or later tallied 6+ starter weeks: Jameis Winston, Josh Allen, Mitchell Trubisky and Dak Prescott.


One third of all top-24 RB finishes last year were found in the first 3 rounds of fantasy drafts. That included Saquon Barkley (15), Christian McCaffrey (15), Ezekiel Elliott (14), Todd Gurley (13) and Alvin Kamara (13).

On the flip side, 5 of the 14 RBs picked in the first 3 rounds tallied 8 or fewer starter weeks. So going RB early wasn’t fool proof.

But it was obviously your best bet to find an elite RB. After Round 4, no other round averaged more than 6 starter weeks per RB. Only 4 RBs drafted after Round 4 — James Conner, Phillip Lindsay, Chris Carson and James White — provided double-digit starter weeks.


While one third of all RB starter weeks were found in the first 3 rounds last year, just 22% of WR starter weeks came from that range. That grows to just less than one third if we expand it to the first 4 rounds — but the takeaway is that WR starter weeks weren’t as condensed to the top of drafts as RBs.

That said, going early-round WR was a nice investment last year. All 11 WRs to go in the first 3 rounds recorded double-digit starter weeks, with 5 of them tallying 12+.

But we could also find 8 other WRs in Round 4 or later who gave us double-digit starter weeks. That includes Julian Edelman in Round 7, Robert Woods in Round 8, Tyler Lockett in Round 13 and Tyler Boyd, who didn’t land in the first 16 rounds in ADP.


Let’s start with this: 40.2% of top 12 TE weeks last season came from TEs drafted outside the first 16 rounds.

Here are the corresponding numbers for starter weeks found outside the first 16 rounds at the other positions:

QB: 9.3%

RB: 25.2%

WR: 33.5%

The problem is that those 82 TE starter weeks came from 43 different guys — just 1.9 weeks per player. That’s why streaming TE is so challenging.

As far as drafting TEs, your best bet last year was either taking 1 super early or waiting until the double-digit rounds. Two of the 3 TEs picked in the first 4 rounds — Travis Kelce and Zach Ertz — were big hits. Rob Gronkowski busted hard.

After that, though, there was very little difference between the TEs in Rounds 5 through 13. The 1 exception was George Kittle in the 12th.


If you’re a fantasy veteran, these results shouldn’t surprise you. There was virtually no difference between the first few DEFs off the board and the DEFs available at the very end of drafts.

Only 5 DEFs tallied 9+ starter weeks last year, and 3 of them went in the 12th round or later. The 3 DEFs that went in single-digit rounds recorded 7, 10 and 5 starter weeks.

What does it mean for 2019?

That’s what we’ll dig in to in Part 2 of this article. We’ll compare value across positions at each round — and then figure out what an ideal draft strategy would have looked like last year.

Related Fantasy Football

Premium Content Premium Content2022 WR Strength of Schedule

2022 WR Strength of Schedule

5 hours ago

How might the end of the schedule treat D.K. Metcalf and others?

Read More »
Premium Content Premium ContentThe Best Stack Values in Underdog Best Ball Mania 3 Drafts

The Best Stack Values in Underdog Best Ball Mania 3 Drafts

9:36am EDT 7/5/22

Looking at projected fantasy points vs. ADP to find the best stack values in Underdog drafts.

Read More »
Premium Content Premium Content2022 RB Strength of Schedule

2022 RB Strength of Schedule

10:00am EDT 6/29/22

What factor just might be working in favor of Devin Singletary's rushing upside this year?

Read More »
Premium Content Premium Content2022 QB Strength of Schedule

2022 QB Strength of Schedule

3:15pm EDT 6/22/22

Before you draft Joe Burrow, you might want to know something about his fantasy football schedule ...

Read More »
Where Did Elite Fantasy Weeks Come From in 2021 Underdog Drafts?

Where Did Elite Fantasy Weeks Come From in 2021 Underdog Drafts?

2:55pm EDT 6/21/22

Where did elite fantasy weeks come from at each position in 2021 Underdog drafts? And what can that teach us about how to draft optimally in 2022?

Read More »
Podcast: Live Best Ball Mania 3 Draft 6-8-22

Podcast: Live Best Ball Mania 3 Draft 6-8-22

10:05pm EDT 6/8/22

Are you drafting in Underdog best-ball tournaments? We're talking strategy, sleepers and surprise picks and we run through a live Best Ball Mania 3 draft.

Read More »
Podcast: Best-Ball ADP Value Check 5-18-22

Podcast: Best-Ball ADP Value Check 5-18-22

10:50am EDT 5/19/22

Matt and Jared look to ADPs from Underdog, FFPC, DraftKings and others to reveal current sleepers in the market and some guys going WAY too early ...

Read More »

Dominate your Fantasy League with

the Ultimate Tool Stack

In the heat of a draft, you want as much intel as possible. The key is integrating that into one simple, powerful tool.

Dominate your Fantasy League with

the Ultimate Tool Stack

In the heat of a draft, you want as much intel as possible. The key is integrating that into one simple, powerful tool.
3D Projections

3D Projections

3D Projections: True Dimension of Every Player’s Potential

Based on our award-winning projections, an axis of data points give insights far deeper than a ranking

View Our Accuracy Awards View Our Accuracy Awards »

Advice Draft Strategy

Advice That’s Actionable on Draft Day

Round-by-Round Draft Strategy Guides, Sleepers, Undervalued Players, Busts and Handcuffs

3D Projections

Draft War Room

Draft War Room: Intel Turned Into Killer Picks

Command your entire draft with a dynamic tool synced to your league. Updating and adapting in real time.

3D Projections

Keep Dominating Throughout The Season

Quickly find the free-agent gems, pull the trigger on the perfect trade & make the right start/sit decisions.

Keep Dominating
Draft Sharks

$6/month thereafter, billed semi-annually, one-click cancel anytime.

Turn your phone into a draft weapon with our FREE APP

Download on the App Store Get It on Google Play