Projected Role & Competition
Young returns as Carolina’s starter this season. The Panthers picked up his fifth-year option in April, keeping him under contract through 2027.
Carolina made a change behind Young, replacing Andy Dalton with Kenny Pickett.
Supporting Cast
The Panthers return last year’s top seven targets, led by WR Tetairoa McMillan. He’s coming off a 70-1,014-7 rookie season in which he ranked 23rd among 76 qualifying WRs in PFF receiving grade. McMillan already looks like a legitimate No. 1 WR and could be better in Year 2.
Carolina will hope to get a healthier season from WR Jalen Coker, who missed the first six games of last year. He averaged 47 yards over his final seven regular-season games, though, and then went off for a 9-134-1 line in the playoff loss to the Rams.
The Panthers added WR Chris Brazzell in Round 3 of this spring’s draft. The 6’4, 198-pounder was one of the top deep threats in the WR class, averaging 15.2 yards per catch in college. He’s probably not ready for a high-volume role but could prove to be an instant upgrade over WR Xavier Legette, who’s been a massive bust through two NFL seasons.
This WR corps looks like it’s ascending, but it’s still unlikely to be better than league average this year.
The TE room looks even less exciting: A hodgepodge of Tommy Tremble, Ja’Tavion Sanders, and Mitchell Evans.
Carolina also has a big question mark at LT after Ikem Ekwonu ruptured the patellar tendon in his right knee in the playoff loss to the Rams. He’s expected to be sidelined for 9-12 months, likely costing him some or most of the 2026 campaign.
The Panthers signed Rasheed Walker to a one-year, $4 million deal in free agency and spent the 19th pick of this spring’s draft on Monroe Freeling as potential fill-ins for Ekwonu. But Young’s blindside protection is a question.
Carolina also lost C Cade Mays to Detroit in free agency. He’s expected to be replaced by Luke Fortner, who has been subpar across four NFL seasons.
Coaching & Offensive Scheme
HC Dave Canales and OC Brad Idzik return for their third season running the Panthers offense. The results have been underwhelming so far:
- 2024: 29th in total yards, 23rd in points
- 2025: 27th in total yards, 27th in points
Canales spent 2023 as the Buccaneers' OC. That team and the 2024 Panthers ran balanced offenses, ranking 15th and 11th, respectively, in pass rate.
Canales shifted run-heavy last year, with the Panthers finishing 23rd in pass rate. Unless Young improves significantly this season, expect a similar run-pass split.
Paths To Ceiling
A decent-enough WR corps and Young’s modest rushing production (career 15.6 yards per game) give him a path to a higher-end QB2 finish. He’ll simply need to play a lot better to get there.
Risk Factors
We already saw Young get benched for a few games in 2024. If he doesn’t improve this year, he might not last the season as Carolina’s starter.