Injury History & Durability
The most pressing question for 2026 is simply whether Jones will be on the field. His December Achilles tear came with a six-to-eight-month recovery timeline. That would bring him back around mid-August at the long end, leaving little margin for setbacks and real risk that he misses games or opens the season compromised.
The bigger concern is whether Jones can replicate his rushing production even if he’s ready for Week 1. A slower start physically could mean fewer designed runs, fewer scrambles, and a tougher path back to five rushing TDs, which mattered a lot to his fantasy value.
Jones returned in 2024 from a Week 9 ACL tear in 2023 and saw his rushing production decline slightly. He averaged 26.5 rushing yards per game with 4 yards per carry. That was down from his career averages to that point of 31.9 rushing yards per game with 5.77 yards per carry.
An Achilles injury could impact rushing even more than an ACL, but Jones slowed down a bit (especially on a per carry basis) after his ACL injury.
Supporting Cast
The supporting cast also took a hit. Michael Pittman Jr. drew a 21.5% target share and ranked 17th among WRs in PPR points before Jones’ injury. The Colts traded him to Pittsburgh after the season and didn’t import any comparable piece.
Alec Pierce now sits atop the WR depth chart after signing a four-year, $114 million extension. He ranked 16th in yards per route run, led the league in target air yards, and set career highs across the board in 2025. But ankle surgery clouds his early-season status, and before last year he’d mostly operated as a deep threat with limited target volume.
Josh Downs returns in the slot bur his playing time was down in 2025. His catches per game at 3.63 were the worst of his career as well. There has been some positive buzz around Downs from GM Chris Ballard
Tyler Warren showed upside at TE as a potential top weapon for the team as well. He certainly profiles as a pass catcher who could make up for Pittman’s departure as a short-to-intermediate target option.
Jonathan Taylor will remain the engine of this offense, especially if Jones’ injury affects the QB’s play. Indianapolis’ run game volume already caps Jones’ pass volume with Taylor leading the league in rushing attempts at 323 in 2025. He will likely be atop the league again and be the Colts’ best path to early offensive success.
Risk Factors
2025 may have shown us Jones’ ceiling. He got to low-end QB1 territory with the team passing more than expected with Jones, but take away Pittman, add uncertainty around Pierce, and factor in real mobility concerns after the injury, and the path back there gets much narrower.
If he’s healthy and Pierce is ready, the efficient passing and favorable system can still make Jones streamable. But with late-round QB depth plentiful, he’s a dart throw rather than a reliable fantasy asset.And like Barkley, Taylor’s receiving doesn’t match the level of the three RBs joining him at the top of the ADP board (Jahmyr Gibbs, Bijan Robinson, and Christian McCaffrey).