Tyler Warren Headshot

Colts TE Tyler Warren ran 26 routes on 32 dropbacks in Thursday night's loss to the Texans, good for an 81% route rate and a strong outing in your points-per-route fantasy leagues. But he was a dud in more standard-scoring formats, catching just 1 of 5 targets for 22 yards. That one catch was a nice contested grab on a back-shoulder throw up the seam. But Warren's other 4 targets had no chance on a night when QB Daniel Jones threw for just 144 scoreless yards.

2026 Fantasy Football Impact: TE1 Value Fading Fast

Warren's playing time has been strong since returning from a groin injury in Week 8. The production has not been. He's somehow managed to turn 25 targets into 11 catches for 85 yards and 0 TDs over the last four games. That's a 44% catch rate, 7.7 yards per catch, and 3.4 yards per target. Truly pathetic.

It's tough to imagine Warren remaining this inefficient, but we've seen it in four straight games now. This Colts offense looks capable of unheard-of levels of ineptitude. Jones has not topped 180 passing yards in any of his last five games, finishing with 144 or fewer in four of them.

Expect to find Warren outside our top-12 TEs in a neutral Week 12 matchup against the Giants. The Colts mercifully get a Week 13 bye.