Trust The Film

Fantasy football is all about the box score: Yards and TDs equal fantasy points, and fantasy points win your league.

But not every 5-100-1 is built the same. That’s why we use not only advanced analytics, but also film to identify talented players on the verge of delivering numbers.

Every week, I’ll bring my 2 years of experience analyzing college and NFL film to highlight when the box score doesn't match reality, showcasing a few players who performed significantly better or worse than the box score indicates.

Tyler Warren, TE, Indianapolis Colts

Headshot of Tyler Warren

Tyler Warren had one of the best pass-catching rookie seasons in Colts history. He and Hall of Fame WR Marvin Harrison (118 in 1996) are the only Colts to lead the team in targets as rookies.

He sits at TE7 in PPR points per game so far this season, but the past three weeks have been rough. Warren hasn’t topped 4 catches in a game and hasn’t scored a TD. That puts him at TE32 in PPG over that period.

Trading away Josh Downs and Keenan Allen should have left the Colts heavily targeting their second-year tight end. But the film shows an offense neutering Warren’s talent both in scheme and support.

Warren runs a drag off of the line on this play, working through traffic to get open underneath against zone coverage. Daniel Jones runs a bootleg and immediately checks down to Warren in the face of pressure.

The throw goes a bit high, forcing Warren to slow down and make a contested catch. He does haul it in, but only for 2 yards.

These types of shallow routes made up most of Warren’s work for the game, sometimes as checkdowns and sometimes just to pull the defense closer to the line. And it didn’t always result in a catch.

Warren runs a similar drag route from inline on this play. He clears the front of the zone with plenty of room to operate after the catch if the pass hits him in stride. The WR in front of Warren could shield LB Kyle Louis and potentially get Warren in the open field against a CB.

But that doesn’t come to fruition.

The Dolphins bring a four-man rush, though one is the nickel CB running free toward Jones. The QB quickly moves to Warren as the checkdown but tosses the ball into the ground as the CB approaches.

The struggles of Jones and the Colts’ O-line have limited Warren’s catchable passes.

When the offense has tried to get creative with Warren, it hasn’t worked out either.

Warren splits out wide on this play for a TE screen.

Warren only played 9.1% of his snaps out wide against the Dolphins, down from his season average of 15.1%. Those plays with Warren out wide typically have been outside runs or passes with him as a primary option (often a screen).

The Dolphins read the formation well, anticipating the screen with LB Jordyn Brooks breaking on Warren before the pass leaves Jones’ hand.

That leads to a 1-yard loss on the catch.

Warren did run a few routes further down the field, but they were typically ineffective in beating the defense.

He runs a 10-yard curl route right into the teeth of the zone on this play. Jones looks that way as a first read, but Warren falters by not moving away from Brooks toward the sideline.

The zone defenders start converging on Warren after seeing Jones looking that way and no other threats on that side of the field. Jones panics and turns to the other side of the field, tossing up a pick-6.

Part of this is on Warren’s awareness, but the lack of another option to pull coverage away from Warren signals poor play design.

The Colts offense simply still utilized Warren as a shallow checkdown option. Jones still couldn’t get him the ball. The scheme and Jones’ execution are limiting Warren’s opportunities. Warren hasn’t been perfect in his spacing, but Indianapolis needs to give him more chances beyond shallow checkdowns.

I expect Jones to stay the same, and that limits Warren’s upside.

The lack of receiving options makes Warren a continued start because he does still present weekly target upside. But don’t be afraid to bench him in a given week if there are more attractive streaming options available in positive matchups.

Jordyn Tyson, WR, New Orleans Saints

Headshot of Jordyn Tyson

Jordyn Tyson was actually my bust pick in our post-draft rookie guide. His college highlights were awesome, but I always felt like his body catching and leaving his feet too often would be problematic in the NFL. Plus, the injuries. That cropped up already, forcing Tyson to miss the first eight weeks with a hamstring injury.

After last week’s film article posted, though, I watched the Saints’ win against the Browns. Tyson immediately stood out, getting open on nearly every route. He only caught 4 of 5 targets for 30 yards but showcased route skill.

That continued into last week with Tyson catching 11 of 13 targets for 80 yards. And the film was excellent once again.

Here’s why my opinion of Tyson has already changed after only two games …

Tyson explodes off the line with a natural bend to slip past the defending CB in this clip. He beats the press and gains separation on a cut to the inside.

Tyler Shough looks to Tyson immediately off the snap and releases a deep pass, but it sails a bit long.

Tyson was often the first read while on the field, drawing a target on 41.9% of his routes. That ranked seventh out of 108 WRs for the week. The film from Week 9 where Tyson was consistently open likely pulled the coaching staff and Shough to make Tyson a priority.

The Saints come back to this play later in the game with more success.

Tyson goes in motion on this play to run another deep crossing route. Tyson once again makes a sharp cut and gains separation when changing direction. This time, Shough rifles the pass accurately to his wideout.

Tyson turns upfield and picks up a few extra yards before getting pushed out by S Tre’von Moehrig.

The motion helps give Tyson momentum off the line for even more separation. The Saints come back to motioning Tyson throughout the game to add to that advantage.

This presnap motion pulls Tyson outside as the ball is snapped. He uses the momentum to force CB Corey Thornton to stay back.

Tyson then drags his back foot during the route to hide his cut from Thornton, sliding into the curl route. Thornton reacts late, allowing an easy throw from Shough to pick up 8 yards.

Tyson put on a clinic on how to run routes and gain separation.

The one downside was his usage. He did play 91% of “11” personnel (1 RB, 1 TE) snaps, taking over that third WR role almost completely from fellow rookie Bryce Lance. But Tyson only played 25% of “12” personnel (1 RB, 2 TE) snaps with only two WRs on the field.

Vele still plays more snaps and runs more routes, leaving room for Tyson’s role to grow.

Even so, the excellent film and production make a case for Saints HC Kellen Moore to utilize Tyson even more. I would bet on that and target him in a trade as the end of the fantasy regular season approaches.

The Saints’ playoff schedule includes a difficult matchup with the Buccaneers in Week 15, but more neutral matchups against the Cardinals and Falcons follow to make Tyson a potentially strong flex play.

I think he’s a dynasty target as well. You could probably move a mid-2027 first for Tyson right now. The sixth or seventh pick in your rookie draft is unlikely to net a WR drafted in the top 10 in 2027, which makes a pick at that level worth giving for this promising receiver.

Cade Klubnik, QB, New York Jets

Headshot of Cade Klubnik

Cade Klubnik opened the second half against Buffalo while Geno Smith was evaluated for a concussion. Smith returned in the third quarter but exited again with an ankle injury.

Klubnik was my top QB in his 2022 recruiting class as a good athlete whose decision making and pinpoint accuracy made him look like the next Trevor Lawrence at Clemson. But that didn’t happen.

Klubnik and the Tigers peaked in his junior season, when he tossed 36 TDs to 6 INTs. As a senior and third-year starter, however, Klubnik displayed a lack of arm strength and threw just 16 TDs amid a struggling Clemson offense.

Watching live, I was intrigued by Klubnik’s no-fear attitude while scrambling and throwing up deep passes. I wanted to dig further into the film to see if there was any hope for Klubnik to become the Jets’ next starting QB.

Klubnik drops back on this play, seeing his first read tightly covered. A defender crashes the flat for the checkdown, so Klubnik decisively takes off on a scramble.

He takes a smart angle moving toward the sideline away from defenders before turning upfield. Klubnik narrowly gets caught on his way toward the end zone, picking up 11 yards.

Klubnik’s explosion and decisiveness are impressive on this play, so expect some scrambles the next time he starts.

Klubnik also shows confidence throwing the football.

He takes the snap on this play, hits a three-step drop, and gives an extra beat for Garrett Wilson’s route to develop. Then Klubnik tosses the pass into the open field hole between the CB and safety.

Wilson slides to make the catch, picking up 29 yards.

The pass could be a little more out in front of Wilson to allow a catch in stride, but the placement is good enough for a deep connection.

Klubnik shows good touch on the pass and shows he can read the defense to put the ball in the right spot.

But Klubnik’s passing was mixed.

Here he locks onto his first read in Wilson again, seeing the deep zone open. But Klubnik doesn’t get the ball deep enough to place it where only Wilson could get it.

Instead, Klubnik lays up the pass a bit short, allowing CB Dee Alford to backpedal into a near INT.

I don’t mind Klubnik’s willingness to take a risky deep shot. Many young QBs hold the ball too long or automatically hit their checkdowns at any sign of trouble. But he does need better ball placement and decision making (including moving to other reads) to develop into a starter.

Klubnik’s performance in this game certainly doesn’t point to him becoming the next face of the Jets’ franchise. But he didn’t play scared or tenuous like most rookie QBs coming in off the bench.

Smith is hoping to play in Week 11. The Jets will evaluate his progress before deciding whether he can start against the Chargers. But I want to see Klubnik get starting reps in practice to see if he can develop a bit more as a QB. I believe the mentality is there for Klubnik to at least be a low-end starter if he develops.

Klubnik is worth adding in superflex redraft leagues in case he gets a shot at some point. He should also be rostered in deep dynasty leagues.