Open Nav
Show Navigation
Show Menu
FANTASY FOOTBALL NEWS

Derek Carr Comes Back to Earth

By Matt Schauf | Updated on Mon, Sep 23 2024 2:53 AM UTC
Derek Carr Headshot

Saints QB Derek Carr threw for just 142 yards in Sunday's loss to the Eagles, with 1 TD and 1 INT. He went just 14-of-25 passing as New Orleans ran 28 times vs. 27 dropbacks.

2024 Fantasy Football Impact

That 56% completion rate marked a significant dip vs. Carr's 76.9% rate over the first two weeks. He also came way down on yards per attempt and TD rate.

We all certainly expected Carr to fall from the unreal efficiency of the first two weeks. But he and the New Orleans offense on whole went from looking like the league's best offense at Dallas to struggling at home against what had been a scuffling Philly D.

Carr did narrowly miss hitting WR Rashid Shaheed for what would have been a 40-yard TD in the second quarter. But he also didn't look good overall.

The Saints now visit Atlanta and Kansas City the next two weeks.

The Falcons have looked better so far on defense than last year. And the Chiefs are capable of playing tough D, especially at home.

After looking like he was becoming a fantasy-starter option, Carr figures to land outside our top 12 the next two weeks.

Other Winners & Losers

The passing volume improved for Saints pass catchers in the team's first non-lopsided outcome of the year. But it'll need to keep shifting to support WRs Chris Olave and Rashid Shaheed on a regular basis.

New Orleans still dropped back on just 48.2% of offensive plays against the Eagles, a rate that would sit at the bottom of the league just about any year.

Matt Schauf Author Image
Matt Schauf, Editor
Matt has earned two Fantasy Pros accuracy awards for IDP rankings and won thousands of dollars as a player across best ball, dynasty, and high-stakes fantasy formats. He has been creating fantasy football content for more than 20 years, with work featured by Sporting News, Rotoworld, Athlon, Sirius XM, and others. He's been with Draft Sharks since 2011.
Premium Content Premium ContentHouston Texans Fantasy Forecast: Can C.J. Stroud and Co. Bounce Back?

Houston Texans Fantasy Forecast: Can C.J. Stroud and Co. Bounce Back?

3 hours ago

A sophomore slump from C.J. Stroud and bad offensive line play made the Texans generally disappointing for fantasy managers last year. Should you bet on a rebound in 2025? Here's your Texans season preview.

Read More »
Draft Smarter in Best Ball: Who to Target, Who to Fade, and How to Find Top Values

Draft Smarter in Best Ball: Who to Target, Who to Fade, and How to Find Top Values

4:28pm UTC 5/19/25

Can Jalen Hurts and Keon Coleman become key factors in your best ball portfolio? And is now a good time to ... (gulp) ... PASS on Jahmyr Gibbs?

Read More »
Video: Dynasty Startup Draft Strategy

Video: Dynasty Startup Draft Strategy

1:53pm UTC 5/17/25

Shane, Jared, and Matt have tons of collective dynasty fantasy football experience. They're pulling from that to talk key startup draft tips and mistakes in this show.

Read More »
Compare Plans » Compare Plans »
THE 2025 ROOKIE GUIDE (V3) IS UPDATED POST-DRAFT!
80 Prospects • Mock Drafts • Trade Values • Model Scores • Analytics & More